I disagree because if someone wanted to go talk about the geo-political consequence of North Korea developing a nuclear program or something similar, there would be a forum for that where people would be looking to actively participate in discussion. At the same time, that same person could also go to a different forum and say something like "girls are fags", comment on how gay rick scarf is or about how Padme is waaaay hotter than Leia etc.
It would more than likely increase traffic and cohesiveness of the site as a whole.
Bookmarks