Thread: DISCORSO MAFIOSO

I say not to lynch anyone. Killing Absolution was a favor.

Hello. I just moved here. I see people have been murdered and now we are going to vote to kill someone every so often. I assure you I am not responsible and shouldn't be killed. Also, I am a little disturbed by the idea of voting on someone's death. But... not disturbed enough to abstain. I vote we lynch Sailor Jack. Why? Because sailors are very similar to pirates. Also there are only ten of us, so we have a pretty good chance of killing the right guy. Take or leave my opinion. I am, after all, just a lowly cittadino.

I would vote Sycld off the island but he's pretty entertaining. But then again, he's pretty gay too...

to get this gay over with asap i will vote for the last player to post on day 1

it couldve been me im not too sure

At first I thought bfdirty was Mr Troy's gimmick. I'm less sure of that now. I equate sailors with pirates, but that's just in the faggot:not faggot ratio (1:0)

Originally Posted by simonj

At first I thought bfdirty was Mr Troy's gimmick. I'm less sure of that now.

I mean, really. Who da fuck is bfdirty? Let's go ahead an lynch him so we can get to day 2.

I don't want to immediately piss off any mafia types if he is a mafia type. Or is that his game?

Let's lynch KT

Originally Posted by simonj

I don't want to immediately piss off any mafia types if he is a mafia type. Or is that his game?

Let's lynch KT

This is an excellent point!

In other news, I stand by my original choice. Maybe sailors and pirates arent the same thing. But do we really want sailors around?



I rest my case.

Originally Posted by sailor jack

i cant help but feel that, if youre not a mafioso, your stereotyping will be manipulated by the mafioso. So you're a liability.

Stereotypes exist because they are mostly true.

Originally Posted by simonj

I voted for KT because, mafia or not, she is fucking sly and were she to be a mafia member she would clearly be the most 'dangerous' one.

Um thanks I guess.

Originally Posted by Think

(Come on Kt; it's so unlikely that bfdirty is a mobster...)

So unlikely? Assuming there are 4 mobsters, he has a 40% chance of being one. That doesn't seem so unlikely, unless you know something I don't.

Ok, here's something else for you to think about. Let's say I was a mobster and bfdirty is innocent. What do I have to gain if he's lynched? Nothing. I would immediately look suspicious for campaigning so hard for his execution and I would probably be voted out the next round. It would be very poor strategy. However, since I am a townperson and not a mobster, I have a 40% chance of being right. And on the 60% chance I'm wrong, Sailor Jack put it best:

Originally Posted by sailor jack

i cant help but feel that, if youre not a mafioso, your stereotyping will be manipulated by the mafioso. So you're a liability.

gonna vote bfdirty

bfdirty as some newcomer comes in, basis on who to kill on false stereotypes of seamen, and then he tries to woo someone who asks to be a mob wife.

LYNCH THAT MOTHERFUCKER BFDIRTY

i doubt bfdirty is mafia unless he is retarded (quite possible) - saying "I assure you I am not responsible and shouldn't be killed." and drawing early attention to himself even though no one knows who he is and has no reason to support him against sailor jack

the fags piling on existing votes (think/shitface/infernus/sailor jack) are more suspicious

Originally Posted by mutton

i doubt bfdirty is mafia unless he is retarded (quite possible) - saying "I assure you I am not responsible and shouldn't be killed." and drawing early attention to himself even though no one knows who he is and has no reason to support him against sailor jack

the fags piling on existing votes (think/shitface/infernus/sailor jack) are more suspicious

a) pretty much what you said about bfdirty
and
b)a werewolf is likely to attack someone who attacks one of their own
and
c)a werewolf is more likely to scapegoat based on factors unrelated to the mechanics of the game (e.g. newness)
means
Kt. was the most likely to be a werewolf given my options

Originally Posted by Think

a) pretty much what you said about bfdirty
and
b)a werewolf is likely to attack someone who attacks one of their own
and
c)a werewolf is more likely to scapegoat based on factors unrelated to the mechanics of the game (e.g. newness)
means
Kt. was the most likely to be a werewolf given my options

A) I agree that bfdirty is an idiot, but if you notice I only voted for him after he practically admitted that he is a mafioso. He even did it again after I accused him. See below:

Originally Posted by bfdirty

Originally Posted by sailor jack

i cant help but feel that, if youre not a mafioso, your stereotyping will be manipulated by the mafioso. So you're a liability.

Stereotypes exist because they are mostly true.

B) Couldn't the same be said about you? I went after someone who may have mob affiliations and then you went after me. And as mutton said:

Originally Posted by mutton

the fags piling on existing votes (think/shitface/infernus/sailor jack) are more suspicious

If I was a mobster and if Sailor Jack was a mobster, it would have been much easier and far more logical to just vote against sycld, who already had a vote against him. Voting against sycld would make it far more likely that Sailor Jack would keep playing. I wouldn't have to worry about someone like bfdirty because if he was a peasant, his Sailor Jack vote would have been completely random.

C) See point A. And besides you could say that Vengeful Scars's vote against sycld (because he's gay) and bfdirty's vote against Sailor Jack (because he's a "sailor") were equally, if not more, suspicious than my vote.


If anything, I think it's more likely that you are part of the mafioso since you attack me after I went after someone who I believe is a mobster and you piled up on an existing vote.

Also kt whilst most of what you said is valid I stand by what I said, I think the wording was quite precise.

Originally Posted by KT.

A) I agree that bfdirty is an idiot, but if you notice I only voted for him after he practically admitted that he is a mafioso. He even did it again after I accused him.

A very clever person might double bluff that way; if you agree that bfdirty is stupid then if he were a mafioso he would play a weak game and avoid looking suspicious. On the supposition of his being retarded, his attention drawing antics speak to his innocence.

Originally Posted by KT.

B) Couldn't the same be said about you? I went after someone who may have mob affiliations and then you went after me.

I specifically said "given my options". Unfortunately at that stage of the game I couldn't see other people doing the same thing as you. Only when I reloaded the page after posting did I notice that that dastardly Think had done precisely the same. It also meant that all the people bandwagoning, which I agree is suspect, came after I had made my first guess.

Originally Posted by KT.

If I was a mobster and if Sailor Jack was a mobster, it would have been much easier and far more logical to just vote against sycld, who already had a vote against him. Voting against sycld would make it far more likely that Sailor Jack would keep playing. I wouldn't have to worry about someone like bfdirty because if he was a peasant, his Sailor Jack vote would have been completely random.

You're a woman so the supposition you would act logically is baffling. But I would argue that the bfdirty bandwagon was obviously more likely than a sycld one. A hypothesis that the game has borne out.

Originally Posted by KT.

C) See point A. And besides you could say that Vengeful Scars's vote against sycld (because he's gay) and bfdirty's vote against Sailor Jack (because he's a "sailor") were equally, if not more, suspicious than my vote.

Yeah, they just seemed like retarded early votes. Yours was the first that could smell of motive.

Originally Posted by KT.

If anything, I think it's more likely that you are part of the mafioso since you attack me after I went after someone who I believe is a mobster and you piled up on an existing vote.

I know what I said above but I'm afraid if you change your vote to me I cannot in that instance follow suit.
As to your reasoning, I can only object that you were the most suspicious character at the time (Come on Kt; it's so unlikely that bfdirty is a mobster...). That doesn't necessarily mean that things haven't changed since then, or won't change still further. That was very early in the game.

forgive me i haven't taken my dried frog pills today
i don't know what i'm saying

lol mafia werewolves

So was bfdirty a mobster or what?

/whore kt

scyld let's see what happens with a tie