Night 2 ends.
One player was swarmed by the Shits, but the Purifier anticipated this move and saved the soon-to-be victim.
Day 3 begins now and ends on Tuesday, August 24 at 11 PM BST.
Night 2 ends.
One player was swarmed by the Shits, but the Purifier anticipated this move and saved the soon-to-be victim.
Day 3 begins now and ends on Tuesday, August 24 at 11 PM BST.
Mutton what time does the day end in EST for the love of fucking christ. You might as well say Day 3 ends once the unicorn cries 12 tears.
Yeah because time zones are so difficult to look up.
Reporting in local time is even easier
/flush coqauvin
I'm not going to immediately vote to flush him, but after Think turned out to be a Brit I'm pretty suspicious of coqauvin. I'd like to hear his defence first.
I too would like to hear Coqauvin.
But if MrShrike carries on accusing me without telling me why or without explaining this mysterious partnership I have with someone secret I'm going to vote to flush him.
I don't think MrShrike is a mafia, but I do think he's a blathering idiot.
oh yeah i forgot to mention my vote is not final, other than just being suspicious i don't have anything solid againts coq
not to mention there's plenty of people that are either laying low or are actually being unusually quiet
Mutton that is ridiculous.
Why don't you tell us who the shits tried to kill last night?
In any other game of mafia that information would be revealed.
Well that's not true either. I've never seen a blocked action revealed.
How many people are left? We have 11 total, 3 mafia remaining, right?
Assuming there is a kill today and a kill tonight, the cop needs to declare himself tomorrow and the doctor should protect him. This turns the odds on the mafia, who now need to scramble to find the doctor.
Sorry for being so late, I've had a busy last couple of days.
Ok, my train of reasoning ran like this. Chances were some of the mafia are going to lay low and stay quiet for as much of the game as they could. Since we're hitting the midgame at about this point, it was pretty reasonable to assume that by Day 2 there would still be at least 1 mafia who wouldn't say anything in an attempt to avoid the shit flinging during the day and getting a kill by night.
I listed three people (KT., Think [RIP] and Snead) who hadn't said much or really contributed to the game at all. I figured if they were town, they would object to my suspicions and lay their own out, or in some way begin an actual game conversation. Instead, KT. called me mafia and voted to lynch me, with reasoning, and think voted to lynch me without reasoning. Fuck, the only thing Think said was:
He didn't even try to defend himself, which, in retrospect, is, I suppose, a sign of innocence(?) I'm still convinced that either KT. or Snead is a Shit. Snead still hasn't said anything to defend himself or accuse anyone, and he hasn't given any message at all that he's not in the game. I find this incredibly suspect. Anne Hathaway, while having the mafiadar of a rock, at least has some reasoning behind what she's doing.Originally Posted by Think
ok valid point
I wish that we had majority voting in this game, because right now voting records are pretty useless in terms of figuring things out.
guys, I'm gonna /flush Snead until another, more obvious choice comes to light.
Well, if we've learnt one thing, Think is terrible at this game.
Profiling time:
Atmoscheer - definitely town. I can't see the nurse protecting mafia who the rest of the mafia votes to kill.
coqauvin - town. I admit my voting record is terrible, but not much worse than anyone else.
infernus - probably town? He was active on day 1, but hasn't been involved since. still unsure
KT. - could be mafia. voted for me with flimsy reasoning, although in her favour, she teamed up with a town on it. i'm significantly less certain of her guilt today than I was day 2
MrShrike - suspicious. He was asking for pro-mafia tactics to be revealed at a sketchy time and kept insisting on them in spite of having a penny on the track of his train of logic. Also he's as confident about his opinions as atmosfear, but without the proof of innoncence or actual intelligence to back it up. At least he's active?
sailor jack - in davy jones' locker.
simonj - probably town. I've seen nothing to trigger my mafia dar. Active all the time, good voting record.
ShitFace - maybe town, but still silent. The only time he's spoken is when the whole 'Shitface is a Shit look at his name' movement on the first day.
Snead - hasn't said a word, not even one to say he isn't/doesn't want to play. suspicious as fuck.
sponge - personally i think he is probably town but you never know
sycld - died of AIDS
Think - dead. Suspicious to me, but that might have been knee-jerk reaction to almost getting lynched. It's not that I mind being lynched, but if I think the Mafia manages to pull off a lynch on a townie without any town support, something is horribly wrong.
WellAdjusted - totally town. Someone this bad at the game would've slipped up as mafia by now.
zuelan - probably town? My voting record isn't particularly great, but I'm still trying to figure out who is mafia. Generally seems to be on the ball, but I can't dedicate myself just yet.
guys, that's all I have on this game. If I get some time in the next couple days, I'll create a voting chart for more info on everyone's actions. I don't know what else to share with you.
edit what a scummy list
Last edited by coqauvin; 09-02-2010 at 05:28 PM.
I would be ok with lynching Snead. It really wouldn't surprise me if he were mafia and the other two mafia have been handling everything with 2-0 majority.
I don't know of any non-mod (or mod) way of seeing the last time a user was active, but I can see from searching that Snead's last post was the sign-up thread. To me, that doesn't indicate especially that he's mafia. It's fucking annoying that he signs up and doesn't play, though.
I wouldn't say I'm bad.. just not uber good
that being said I do not have a vote yet
Rocket science it is not.
Of course that may not mean anything, but is definitely suggestive.
I have other suspicions, some of which I have already outlined, others I haven't just yet.
I'm less sure now than I was day ago that Atmosfear and Simonj are in cahoots (although then why the big drama llama and bullshit??) but that's something else I will need to consider.
Seeing as we have some time yet and I'm busy at work, I'm going to think on it a little bit further before I put forward my vote and rationalisations. Coq as far as I'm concerned I've explained my reasoning a number of times and I don't think it needs anything further. Your own position is not exactly beyond suspicion, although I'm not accusing you of anything at this point.
wtf? That's exactly what I did. I objected to your suspicions and I laid out my own suspicions.I listed three people (KT., Think [RIP
And the reason I haven't said much is because there isn't much to say. Day one was a waste and pretty much the major threads of conversation so far are why it is or is not a good idea to give pro-mafia tips on how to play the game during a game or something completely off topic.
And what is this "voting record" of which you speak? Not counting when sycld basically committed suicide, we've only voted once and I don't think you can deduce much from just one vote.
snead seems like a valid choice aswell, perhaps the lack of solid suspicion comes from the lack of information (silent players) but i'm not entirely convinced just yet, since it could also be because theres really not much to talk about. so yes i'm not entirely convinced just yet
while Think getting lynched might have something to do with it, i'm willing to accept it wasn't intentional, i had limited internet access (and suck at this game) and couldn't make an educated guess myself.
then there's the whole healer request thing
i don't know if that affected your profiling at all, btw, and yes, i realize i too, supported the idea of having a healer, but if i had any interest in making a cover work i wouldn't want anyone to take a second glance at this comment.
i'd really like to hear infernus oppinion at this point, he has also been quiet.
Last edited by zuelan; 08-23-2010 at 03:43 AM.
Coq when you post a voting chart, make sure you include vote switches.
I'm hiding in the shadows
Day 1
Atmoscheer - sycld bandwagon
coqauvin -mutton, clearly serious / sycld bandwagon
infernus - sycld bandwagon
KT. -sycld bandwagon
MrShrike
sailor jack -sycld, drunk as fuck
simonj -Shitface, not serious / -mr shrike after shrike's reasoning about sycld / simonj
ShitFace - sycld bandwagon
Snead
sponge -sycld "darkie faggot, lynching last time good move"
sycld
Think
WellAdjusted -Zuelan "no reason to first votes" / sycld bandwagon
zuelan -sycld, who said he was a shit
after this, sailor jack and sycld are removed from the list.
I'm too busy to finish day two right now, but i'll have it up before the end of the night
its not so much bandwagoning as it is revenge tbh
/lynch snead
Although every time MrShrike posts he appears more and more suspicious, instead of just appearing retarded.
Day 2
Code:Atmoscheer - Think / MrShrike coqauvin -Think infernus - KT. -coqauvin MrShrike -simonj / Atmoscheer simonj -coqauvin, maybe joking / Think ShitFace - Snead sponge - WellAdjusted -simonj zuelan -
thanks atmosfear
also, in regards to:
I don't think that silence is completely indicative of guilt, but I don't have anything else to go on. I'm still reasonably sure that some mafioso is gonna be trying to lay low. At this point, if Snead was actually playing, he definitely would've spoken up to defend himself by now. The only others that would fit this profile (and the more I dwell on it, the flimsier it gets, tbh) are infernus and shitface, because they haven't participated since the beginning of day 1 and haven't really tried to contribute anything since then. That being said, this is only through the lens of 'silence implies guilt' which isn't absolute.
The only other lead I think we have is mrshrike, but that's either guilt or just ignorance and I can't tell with him.
It's true, that would make a good cover. But the only thing that makes me suspect infernus at this point is his lack of participation, because I don't have anything else to go on.
I'll be randomly getting back to various points in the thread because I'm a little tipsy today
If theres one person I'd say isnt it would be atmos. hes almost too good as a cit. If someone was acting very in between to me it would be Coq he seems sort of neutral but this is just from memory and not from going back and revising this thread which I might do later. So for now im abstaining from voting
This is why I'm retaining a tiny bit of suspicion for atmosfear. For now I'll believe he's legit but if we've caught no mafia by day 4 or 5 then I know where my vote will likely go.
how come you haven't voted to lynch him again?
current votes
11 PM BST = 6 PM Eastern = 3 PM PacificCode:votes against voted to flush Atmoscheer 0 coqauvin 1 Snead infernus 0 KT. 0 MrShrike 0 simonj 0 Snead ShitFace 0 Snead 2 sponge 0 WellAdjusted 0 zuelan 0 coqauvin
just gonna point out that the mafia tried to kill atmosfear. He is unimpeachably town.
I am interested in hearing this.
Errr....how the fuck do you know that?
Is that true Atmosfear?
if he is telling the truth then he is probably the nurse
but he isn't. revealing such information would potentially get him or atmosfear killed on the next night, and coq is not dumb. he just made an educated guess (one i would agree with), or hes just bluffing his way out of suspicion (a potential dumb move aswell)
i'll go with educated guess.
Shit, well I hadn't considered that, but yeah he could be the nurse as well.
Either he is
A) mafia and just fucked up
B) nurse and just fucked up
C) drunk and just fucked up (very unlikely)
I don't think there's any way of settling it for sure. If he is mafia, the real nurse standing up is NOT a good move by the way.
I have to go to a dinner party, so I'm just going to go with the balance of votes so far and vote to /flush Coqauvin I might be finished in time before it becomes nighttime and see if Coq has any sort of plausible explanation and what else develops, but any explanation would need to be a bloody good one.
also remember that coqauvin modded the last mafia game, his chances of fucking up as a nurse are pretty low
i won't change my vote just yet. he's fairly capable and i'd hate to see him lynched if hes a townsperson, but i see no other candidate.
I can confirm that I was the target of the mafia.
I'll explain in detail once I get to work. I think we now know 2 of 3 mafia.
Mutton, we need to extend the deadline. This is big news.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks