Why would an innocent start the game double bluffing? Sycld is either innocent or mafia, but if he doesn't want to play, he doesn't want to play.

MrShrike just because you are wrong doesn't mean you aren't valuable. Someone who knows the rules and tries to understand the multiple angles of the game, even if misguided, is more valuable than someone who isn't active or is only mildly interested in playing effectively to a successful outcome.

I'd rather lynch a Shit but since it's a random vote day, might as well kill the disinterested.