Quote Originally Posted by MrShrike View Post
Well except that several people know who the nurse is, which makes him a potential target if one of them is mafia. Which you know damn well.
Sponge knew all the people who knew his identity (Atmosfear, MrShrike, ShitFace, infernus.) There are a number of reasons he may not have protected himself; I was simply rejecting your (terrible) advice that the Nurse should always protect himself.

Quote Originally Posted by MrShrike View Post
And now, why would you suggest a vote for me next round, when you know perfectly well that that I am not a mafia?
I don't know that. I know that I suspect ShitFace more than you, for the reasons you mentioned (his suspicious lack of activity) and the reasons I mentioned (sponge's death looks too convenient to be random.

Quote Originally Posted by MrShrike View Post
The more I think about it, the more I think there is pretty much only 1 way a mafia could virtually guarantee victory for themselves. It would require a few coincidence, but aside from that, it's entirely feasible.

1. Find out who the nurse is and have them protect you.
2. Vote to kill yourself.
3. Reveal to everyone that you were the target the next day and thus MUST of course be innocent(!)
4. Reveal to a number of others who the nurse is, thus making them the suspects if the nurse dies
5. Tell then nurse to continue protecting you, instead of themseles, then kill the nurse which also proves beyond a shadow of a doubt that you are innocent and removes them from play later in the game.
Jesus Christ, that is so stupid on so many levels. Sure, that would be one way to win, but considering that I served up two mafia when there were no meaningful suspects (I confirmed that another nurse had spoken to me when I easily could have stayed quiet or denied anything related to coqauvin), as well as considering that coqauvin and I were the first two people to actually speak out against Snead, and I found his last post (after which you then found the "Latest Activity" that didn't require ModCP.) I was also the first to vote for him again on Day 4.

Oh, then there's this little issue of KT and Infernus, who were proven to be Sheriff and Town, respectively. In post #241 of this thread, Infernus confirms that he received a PM from KT stating that she had investigated me and that I was town. I really don't see how it's even possible for a mafia to fake that, since both are dead and their identities are proven, or why a sheriff would lie to a town she had investigated about the identity of a mafia (which would have had to be true for Infernus to have lied.) I'm sure you'll MrShrike a way to blame that on me being mafia, though, even though I'm clearly unimpeachable.

Quote Originally Posted by MrShrike View Post
It's a diabolical plan, but you are very friendly with sponge and I have no doubts he would have taken the risk to tell you he was the nurse of his own initiative. Plus that would allow you to bandwagon the lynch I initiated again Coquavin, and to even start the lynch against the other likely suspect Snead without hesitation, because while they would be helpful, in your unimpeachable position, you ultimately don't need them.
While I wish I was that manipulative and able to control all of the variables you've described, unfortunately that's a snowball's chance in hell that anyone could ever pull it off, especially from the position of strength the mafia was in with 3 unknowns.

You didn't really start a bandwagon against coqauvin--he slipped up and revealed he had to be either mafia or the nurse. Like I said before, I confirmed that another nurse had revealed himself to me, so that it was 50-50 that either coq or the silent person (now known to be sponge) was mafia.

Quote Originally Posted by MrShrike View Post
Again, you know I'm not mafia yet next round you plan on trying to lead a lynch against me. Previously, you were happy as long as I was singing your praises, but now I need to go, despite having shown my innocence. I spotted and started the lynched against Coq. I was the one who made Snead a suspect when no-one was even looking at him. I vouchsafed for you. It doesn't make sense for you to put my name up for lynching next unless you are mafia.

/flush atmosfear
Again, I don't know you're town, but I suspect that someone who knew that sponge was the nurse was responsible for killing him, since it was a 1 in 5 (?) shot (there were 5 town and 1 mafia left, right?) I suspect ShitFace ahead of you, but I wanted to throw out that suspicion in case I am killed.

Truthfully, after WellAdjusted voted, I was leaning more towards her than you or ShitFace... Voting for me is absolutely retarded because I've been proven by the Sheriff to be town.