The Town still can't lose (even on the kill night, we can switch to protect Van Helsing--we'll have enough town confirmations), and the game is even less fun, because now only a couple players are even playing.
This game doesn't need a re-do. It needs to just stop. Mafia is predicated on an informed minority defeating an uninformed majority. When the majority has a single beacon of truth that is guaranteed to be on its side, it can accumulate information too easily and it basically can't lose.
With large enough numbers, this game setup could be more reasonable, but we aren't going to get them. I told you to give it up, but no one fucking listens to Atmosfear and I have to be the one to go and break the game.
Bookmarks