I really dislike your reponse. It just feels slimy.

Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
I pointed out a mistake in atmoscheer's post. I found the mistake suspect as Atmoscheer isn't normally the type to make mistakes in a probablility analogy but that was just me being paranoid (yeah, I get paranoid, it has got me lynched in the past).
But, he didn't make a mistake. Here's the exchange:

Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Atmoscheer View Post
Past roles have no effect on the current game. Lynching sycld for being mafia three times before is like betting a coin will be heads because it's been tails on the last three flips.
No it isn't.
/unlynch sponge
/lynch atmoscheer because he's been tails on the last three flips
Quote Originally Posted by Atmoscheer View Post
Past roles have no effect on the current game. Lynching sycld for being mafia three times before is like betting a coin will be heads because it's been tails on the last three flips.
Quote Originally Posted by Atmoscheer View Post
simonj are you stupid or just mafia?
Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
It was hardly a serious accusation, I was pointing out the error in your post (voting for sycld because he's been mafia so often is like betting a coin will be tails because it has been tails on the last three flips, voting for you because you haven't been mafia is like betting a coin will be heads because it's been tails on the last three flips, both are stupid because, as you know, each flip has the same 50/50 outcome and previous results make no difference)
Quote Originally Posted by Atmoscheer View Post
That exactly what I said. The odds of sycld being mafia this game are independent of the outcomes of previous games.

You both said the exact same fucking thing. Where is the mistake? You just swapped heads for tails and said you fixed it. That's almost as dumb as sponge hammering Atmosfear instead of waiting one night for him to respond. Responses are more valuable than a straight flip because they give flips context. What's the point of that?


Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
I voted to lynch sponge before his reasoning was apparant (it was in another thread which I hadn't read - I thought I made that clear). Once it WAS apparant I raised my suspicions of sycld (which you share).
This is valid.

Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
And, yes, I'm aware I often make stupid jokes in mafia games too, I wasn't condemning sycld for it, just pointing out that it makes figuring out what lies behind his posts quite difficult.
Yes, and the same goes for yourself.

Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
I also wouldn't exactly say I targeted sycld (I didn't actually vote to lynch him)
Which gains you Skrull points.

Quote Originally Posted by simonj View Post
just pointed out that he was logically the next choice to pressure.
Logically.

The way you frame your response bothers me. You're trying so hard to sound innocent it interferes with explaining your actions. This desire to appear innocent, or the need to appear innocent is suspect to me.

My vote stays where it is. I'm rather confident that simonj is mafia.