Quote Originally Posted by Atmosfear View Post
He's halfway through a career that is hall of fame quality without star billing and he's going to retire with peyton manning tossing to him. You forget that this is the fantasy era and people recognize these niche performers.
The HoF voters have a tendency to ignore "these niche performers", and vote in the true greats. Although Carter SHOULD HAVE BEEN FIRST GOD DAMNED BALLOT!

Reggie Wayne is good, but he's not in the elite class of WR's. I think Marvin Harrison, I think "Wow, he is one of the greatest to ever play his position." I get the same with LT and Derrick Brooks.

Someone is only worthy of being a Hall Of Famer when there is no doubt in everybody's mind that they were truly great.