I really don't know what to tell you. I'm not super suspicious of anyone. As I'm not privvy to atmosfear's information I don't know who to narrow down although I understand revealing this information is potential suicide.
The fact we've had so many players stay quiet certainly doesn't help. Sponge, Snead, Shitface and Infernus have all made no discerning votes (I'm not counting votes against sycld). You and WellAdjusted have only made one vote each since day 1 ended and Atmoscheer, MrShrike & myself are the only players to cast votes on all 3 days.
I find MrShrike most suspicious but I don't want a knee-jerk anti-idiot response to get in the way of actual logic.
Bookmarks