Quote Originally Posted by coqauvin View Post
Atmosfear, I was surprised that you trusted MrShrike enough to give him the Nurse's identity. Actually, I was surprised that, in a field of 9~ players, you gave the identity away to almost half of them. A better play would've been using different names for each player you gave it to with only one obvious townie getting the real one. When that player dies randomly in the night, you'll have a better time of narrowing down who it is.
Funnily enough, that's exactly what I argued with him at the time, privately. Although he'd already decided how to do it by then without my input, so I was merely legitimising myself.

I think either way is arguable and has pros and cons depending on the situation.