Atmosfear - kudos if the double mafia theory is correct - but I can't see why serial killer/vigilante and nurse doesn't explain last night better than two families would.
My concern is, if this is wrong, even if it's right to an extent, it is hugely maladaptive for the town to think in this way. It makes all the people who are most town open to suspicion because they're killing mafia - if that isn't a narrative open to mafia abuse then I don't know what is. Combine it with your statement just now that mafia vote to lynch mafia and you can see why it's beginning to come off as subversive to me.
So whilst I think that you may well be right (the "vinyl tap" designation does sound like it's there to distinguish different groups, there are other meta reasons it would make sense, like the ban on PMs), and I admit that I might be blinded somewhat by my suspicion that mutton is not only a mafioso but is "vinyl tap", I don't see pressing in-game reasons to accept the hypothesis, and I wonder whether you have a way to turn it into an action plan without it devolving into us eating our young.
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks