Thread: LOST [Spoilers]

Originally Posted by gwahir

we have no reason to believe that she was a smoke monster specifically

it seems weird that she'd be a monster AND the guardian, which she was

Originally Posted by KT.

Also, how else would a middle-aged lady kill a bunch of people, drag a full grown man out from the bottom of a well and then destroy said well?

Her being both wouldn't be any more weird than the rest of the show.