"all but officially cleared" and "investigated" are NOT the same thing, dude. MPR is a new player, he easily could have misread KT as a bluffing mafia. Even if it was just a small chance of failure, there was actually ZERO chance of not knowing who the mafia was if I had lived. So I challenge you again: if there's even the slightest disadvantage, it's a suboptimal play.
The benefit of hindsight doesn't change the odds. One play guarantees you a win regardless of Nermy's action (protect Atmosfear.) The other required a player to decide who to kill based on imperfect information. You're acting like there's some advantage or extra win condition if you also block a cop kill... At the point she tried to block, it wouldve been meaningless.
Bookmarks