Quote Originally Posted by WellAdjusted View Post
The first game I can remember beating is Super Mario Bros. 3.

I used both whistles the first time I legit beat it, though. I guess it would be pokemon yellow after that.
The first game I remember beating was Mario 3 also. I have fond memories of beating Turtles in Time also. But honestly I don't finish many games. Either the gameplay has to be super awesome, the story has to yank me in, it has to be pretty short, or I have to have nothing to do. The game I am currently failing to be able to get it up to play all the way through is Final Fantasy XIII.