It was a decent movie, but if they had found a way to bust it up into two 2+ hour movies, then they might be able to do the graphic novel justice. But I'm not sure that there is a good "stopping point" halfway through the original story that would make people want to watch the sequel two years later...

Another thing that bothered me was the pronunciation of Rorschach's name. It's a German name, god dammit. ROAR-SHOCK. The "a" is pronounced with a short "o" sound. Not "ROR-SHACK". Not "RAW SHARK"

Rorschach and Comedian were portrayed extremely well. I only wish they played up a little more Rorschach's bad hygiene, as the first and only time it was mentioned was
Spoiler
. Dunno if that's even spoiler-worthy.

The Comedian was hilarious, exactly as I would expect his comic version to translate to the big screen. A cocky smug asshole who has committed jorrible atrocities in his lifetime, but not necessarily someone you would hate outright.

Hmmm...the only other thing that comes to mind is Silk Spectre I....comic version vs. film version...yeah I think they did good by her in the movie (her young version). I never did like the hair she sported in the comic.